Automated vs. Manual Dishwashing: Improving Productivity & Compliance

May 19, 2020 by Hobart


It seems like a given that an automatic dishmachine would reduce labor in any situation. But just how much time can a dishmachine save? Hobart recently conducted a study to put that assumption to the test. What we found was that using an automatic dishwasher not only leads to improved productivity, but also savings in water use and improved food safety.

Labor Savings Comparisons

In our study, we compared two locations from the same restaurant chain, one that used a 3-compartment sink for all dishwashing, and one that used the Hobart AM15SCB door-type commercial dishwasher.

Our results showed up to a 40% reduction in washing time when using the automated dishwasher. Not only was less time spent washing dishes, but staff using the AM15SCB dishmachine were able to load dishes and then do other activities while the washing took place, leading to improved overall productivity.

  • 3-Compartment Sink Washing: Wash sessions with the 3-compartment sink often lasted from 15–40 minutes. Most days had one session that lasted around 40 minutes and several other sessions that lasted 15–20 minutes.
  • Machine Washing: During our study, most dishwashing sessions were 1–3 minutes. Staff could partially load a rack and finish loading it later, so no one person was tied up just washing ware.

Food Code Compliance

Our study also looked at two areas of compliance: wash water temperature and sanitization practices. The AM15SCB door-type dish machine provides consistent washing and sanitization, and is designed with lockouts that help to prevent the machine from running if the proper temperature is not achieved or if chemicals required for sanitization are empty.

In comparison, our study found multiple issues of compliance at the site relying on hand washing in the 3-compartment sink. When using a 3-compartment sink, the 2017 FDA food codes require a minimum of 110 degrees Fahrenheit for the wash sink. During our study, 85% of the total manual washing time was below the 110 degree requirement. This was due to two factors. First, while the facility’s water heater was capable of providing water at 120 degrees, there were times when the initial wash sink fills didn’t reach 110 degrees. Second, the lag time between when the sink was filled and when staff began washing allowed the water to cool below 110 degrees.

Sanitization was also an issue. The 2017 FDA Food Code requires submersion in the sanitization sink for a minimum of 30 seconds when using a Quaternary Ammonium sanitizer, but our study found a significant amount of ware was submerged for less than the required time in the sanitization sink. Many items were dipped in and out quickly during the sanitization step with less than 2 seconds of submersion. Large items, such as sheet pans, would not be turned around in the sink, leaving them only half submerged and half sanitized. When working with other large items like cutting boards, carafes, and slicers that are difficult to fit in the sinks, many operators were observed splashing water from the sanitizer sink onto the ware, randomly hitting some of the surfaces and missing other surfaces.

Finally, while tracking operator behavior during our study we found that the wash, rinse and submerge and sanitize process wasn’t always followed in the proper order, and sometimes staff even skipped steps, including sanitization.

Clear Benefits

In our study of two locations, the results weighed heavily in favor of an automatic dishmachine in three areas:

  1. Labor savings. The Hobart AM15SCB dishmachine reduced daily labor time up to 40%.
  2. Water savings. The Hobart AM15SCB reduced water consumption by 68% compared to the 3-compartment sink. That’s a savings of almost 55,000 gallons per year!
  3. Food code compliance. The Hobart AM15SCB’s temperature and chemical lockouts greatly reduce the probability of user error in washing and sanitizing.

Click here to read the full manual vs. automated dishwashing case study.

Why risk it? Compare more of the risks and benefits with our warewashing infographic at 


Learn more about the Hobart AM15SCB Door Type Dishmachine

Tags: Dishwashing


Latest Posts

Labor Savings & Food Safety: Undercounter Dishmachines vs. 3 Comp Sinks

July 07, 2023 by Hobart

Study Shows Undercounter Dishmachines Save Labor & Improve Food Safety

If your food service operation relies on manual washing in a three-compartment sink, upgrading to an undercounter commercial dishwasher can significantly improve labor and resource efficiency, as well as food safety. In a recent field study with a QSR operation using a three-compartment sink versus operation with an LX Undercounter Dishmachine, Hobart engineers found an automated dishmachine provided measurable savings in labor time and water consumption, and drastic improvements in food safety and sanitization assurance.

Read More

Choosing Disposable or Reusable Ware for K12 Food Service

April 01, 2022 by Hobart

Each year, an estimated 7.5 to 8 billion breakfasts and lunches are served to K-12 students across the United States. The type of ware used to serve those meals in some ways is just as important as the food that’s on it, and plays a big role in determining the budget, labor needs and waste management for a food service operation.

Many school systems relied on disposable ware programs during the height of the COVID-19 pandemic, even if they had a reusable ware program before the pandemic. Disposables made it easy to package and deliver to-go meals to students doing remote school and helped address concerns over contamination for on-site education. Now as we emerge from COVID-19 restrictions, K-12 food service is being impacted by additional factors including budgets, availability of supplies and storage space, labor costs, and sustainability expectations and mandates. Many schools are reconsidering their ware programs and making the switch to reusables.

Read More

Even Greener Than Before - Commercial Dishwashers & ENERGY STAR 3.0

July 09, 2021 by Hobart

Effective July 27, 2021, all commercial dishwashers sold with the ENERGY STAR label will have to meet new, more stringent guidelines and testing requirements set by the ENERGY STAR program, a joint program between the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency and the Department of Energy. Hobart is ready with dishmachine models from across our entire product line that are certified to the new standards. 

Read More

What’s Your Time Worth? Reducing Labor in the Dishroom

April 06, 2021 by Hobart

Time is money, and no one understands that old adage more is better than an employer who pays employees by the hour. What if there was a way to reduce the amount of time dishroom operators have to spend pre-soaking and scraping dishes before loading them into the dishmachine, and instead gives them more time to do other productive tasks around the kitchen? The Automatic Soil Removal (ASR) technology on select Hobart commercial dishwashers reduces time spent prescrapping, leading to dishwashing labor savings by 20% or more.

Read More

How Clean are Your Dishes? Cleaning Tough Foods with Less Effort

March 25, 2021 by Hobart

Anyone who has spent time soaking and scrubbing dried-up, crusty foods and grease off dishes, prep ware and pots and pans knows just how tough and time consuming some foods soils are to remove. Some of the top offenders are eggs, cheese, pie filling and tomato-based sauces, and anything with a high sugar or fat content is a prime culprit in baked-on, dried-up or greasy food messes.

Thanks to these tough foods, scrapping and soaking are necessary processes in the dishroom. But with the right equipment in place the time spent on these labor-intensive tasks can be reduced, leading to increased productivity and cost savings in the kitchen.

Read More